scientific-thinking-scholar-evaluation
Reviews research papers and proposals to check if the evidence is strong and the thinking is sound.
Installation
Paste this into Claude Code, Cursor, or any agent that can run commands.
What this skill does
What it does:
- Scores academic or scientific papers using a structured rubric with nine dimensions like research questions, literature review, methods, data quality, analysis, results, limitations, writing, and citations
- Assigns scores from 1 to 5 for each dimension, where 5 means excellent and ready to publish, and 1 means major problems
- Identifies critical issues that block acceptance and suggests specific revisions
- Compares multiple papers using the same rubric to rank them
When to use it:
- You need to evaluate a research paper, proposal, thesis chapter, or literature review
- You want to check if claims are supported by the sources cited
- You need to assess whether the methods and research design are sound
- You want to compare two or more papers to see which is higher quality
- You need structured feedback to guide revisions before submitting work
The full skill text could not be loaded right now. It installs fine with the command above, or read it at the source.
Mirrored from the author's public source. Install counts from the open skills registry.